My first impression of this song was that it was far too adorable, that these guys were indulging their worst folksy precious moments impulses. Then, one day, while out for a walk, it came up on my iPod and I didn’t recognize it at all, and I thought it might be some stray old Guster song that I’d forgotten about, and I fell sort of in love with it. So, okay, maybe I should give their new album The Carpenter a real chance after all.